Dubai Telegraph - Climate migrants could face a world of closing doors

EUR -
AED 3.870573
AFN 71.062782
ALL 98.638665
AMD 424.212636
ANG 1.900543
AOA 962.642141
ARS 1066.699929
AUD 1.63605
AWG 1.896833
AZN 1.807139
BAM 1.963263
BBD 2.129194
BDT 126.010221
BGN 1.95858
BHD 0.397291
BIF 3050.739374
BMD 1.053796
BND 1.419681
BOB 7.2867
BRL 6.357386
BSD 1.054509
BTN 89.370589
BWP 14.4059
BYN 3.450493
BYR 20654.401287
BZD 2.12558
CAD 1.482143
CDF 3025.448712
CHF 0.930459
CLF 0.037251
CLP 1027.862453
CNY 7.655197
CNH 7.66518
COP 4652.899174
CRC 535.340165
CUC 1.053796
CUP 27.925594
CVE 110.648347
CZK 25.169178
DJF 187.280529
DKK 7.457619
DOP 63.702046
DZD 140.923788
EGP 52.483784
ERN 15.80694
ETB 131.988165
FJD 2.398387
FKP 0.831779
GBP 0.82857
GEL 3.003062
GGP 0.831779
GHS 15.933567
GIP 0.831779
GMD 74.819726
GNF 9094.259093
GTQ 8.140021
GYD 220.618677
HKD 8.20347
HNL 26.618565
HRK 7.517
HTG 138.166548
HUF 413.43895
IDR 16750.087166
ILS 3.816238
IMP 0.831779
INR 89.279492
IQD 1380.472739
IRR 44364.810754
ISK 145.507935
JEP 0.831779
JMD 165.996546
JOD 0.747248
JPY 158.208521
KES 136.454174
KGS 91.469913
KHR 4247.851911
KMF 492.781365
KPW 948.415986
KRW 1489.024078
KWD 0.324063
KYD 0.878749
KZT 554.101664
LAK 23130.822189
LBP 94420.119706
LKR 306.234143
LRD 188.629654
LSL 19.063456
LTL 3.111585
LVL 0.63743
LYD 5.152966
MAD 10.524783
MDL 19.308584
MGA 4947.571977
MKD 61.536517
MMK 3422.68825
MNT 3580.798697
MOP 8.455544
MRU 42.067925
MUR 49.181091
MVR 16.291982
MWK 1828.33617
MXN 21.362352
MYR 4.692023
MZN 67.347811
NAD 19.063036
NGN 1715.906556
NIO 38.727367
NOK 11.617231
NPR 142.992942
NZD 1.795713
OMR 0.405712
PAB 1.054509
PEN 3.939088
PGK 4.254702
PHP 61.298787
PKR 292.823561
PLN 4.279346
PYG 8227.275822
QAR 3.836843
RON 4.977181
RSD 116.958694
RUB 110.628131
RWF 1459.507438
SAR 3.959635
SBD 8.797673
SCR 14.719124
SDG 633.855401
SEK 11.49546
SGD 1.414513
SHP 0.831779
SLE 23.973542
SLL 22097.579878
SOS 602.24393
SRD 37.309633
STD 21811.449264
SVC 9.227077
SYP 2647.693874
SZL 19.063055
THB 36.060919
TJS 11.509955
TMT 3.688286
TND 3.320516
TOP 2.468096
TRY 36.595705
TTD 7.153261
TWD 34.14225
TZS 2771.483327
UAH 43.916506
UGX 3880.752602
USD 1.053796
UYU 45.533093
UZS 13525.47214
VES 50.352654
VND 26776.955954
VUV 125.108777
WST 2.941767
XAF 658.466395
XAG 0.033566
XAU 0.000397
XCD 2.847936
XDR 0.801927
XOF 655.461172
XPF 119.331742
YER 263.817544
ZAR 19.081226
ZMK 9485.42613
ZMW 28.550534
ZWL 339.321877
  • CMSC

    0.0000

    24.56

    0%

  • RBGPF

    -1.0000

    61

    -1.64%

  • CMSD

    0.1100

    24.42

    +0.45%

  • SCS

    -0.1000

    13.42

    -0.75%

  • RYCEF

    0.1100

    7.55

    +1.46%

  • RELX

    0.4550

    47.935

    +0.95%

  • RIO

    -0.0800

    63.43

    -0.13%

  • NGG

    -0.6950

    62.275

    -1.12%

  • VOD

    -0.0400

    8.79

    -0.46%

  • GSK

    -0.3450

    34.555

    -1%

  • BCE

    -0.5350

    26.775

    -2%

  • BTI

    0.1500

    37.18

    +0.4%

  • JRI

    -0.0830

    13.457

    -0.62%

  • BCC

    -1.2000

    145.23

    -0.83%

  • AZN

    -1.4800

    66.57

    -2.22%

  • BP

    -0.3550

    29.095

    -1.22%

Climate migrants could face a world of closing doors
Climate migrants could face a world of closing doors

Climate migrants could face a world of closing doors

People driven from their homes as global warming redraws the map of habitable zones are unlikely to find refuge in countries more focused on slamming shut their borders than planning for a climate-addled future, according to a top expert on migration.

Text size:

From fleeing a typhoon to relocating in anticipation of sea level rise, climate migration covers a myriad of situations and raises a host of questions.

But one thing is sure: the number of climate refugees is going to increase in the coming decades, according to a major UN report on climate impacts and vulnerability released on Monday.

"We are on the cusp of a major environmental change that is going to redistribute populations on a planetary scale," Francois Gemenne, a lead author of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) report, told AFP.

"But clearly -- given the current political climate -- we are not at all ready to confront this kind of question," he said in an interview.

"Rather, there's a tendency to shutter borders and erect walls topped with razor wire."

Which is why the temptation to raise the spectre of mass climate migration in order to spur more aggressive action in curbing carbon pollution is so dangerous, said Gemenne, a professor at Liege University in Belgium.

"Even if it's done with the best of intentions, this risks reinforcing xenophobic attitudes," he said.

But the problem is already here-and-now, even if so-called "climate migrants" have no legal status, nationally or internationally.

- Environment is economy -

"In 2020, some 30 million people were displaced by extreme weather events made worse by climate change -- three times more than the number displaced by violence or conflict," Gemenne said.

Most people forced to abandon their homes due to droughts, storms and floods made worse by global warming are in the global South, and most remain within the borders of their countries.

Many of those who do wind up on the edge of Europe or the southern border of the United States are often labelled "economic migrants", suggesting that they are pulled by opportunity rather than pushed by catastrophe, Gemenne said.

"My salary and yours does not depend on environmental conditions," Gemenne said. "But for a lot of people on this planet who depend on rain-fed agriculture, the economy and the environment are the same thing."

Sea level rise alone could displace hundreds of millions of people by century's end, with low-lying coastal regions expected to be home to more than a billion people by 2050, according to the IPCC report.

Vast expanses of agricultural land, particularly in deltas, are also at risk.

But predictions of how many climate migrants there might be in 30, 50 or 80 years are confounded by unknown variables and choices not yet made.

"It's very complicated and hard to say because we're talking about human behaviour, which can sometimes be irrational", Gemenne said.

"It's not really something that the IPCC can model."

- A 'virtual state'? -

The best projections to date may come from the World Bank, which has calculated up to 216 million people could be internally displaced by mid century, even under an optimistic greenhouse gas emissions scenario.

Although Gemenne said that does not mean this number will definitely be forced from their home.

Impacts can be softened by early warning systems, financial compensation or long-term planning, he added.

Indonesia recently made the extraordinary decision to move its capital to Borneo from Jakarta, on the island of Java, because the megapolis is being overtaken by rising seas and sinking due to depleted aquifers.

Rich countries "under the impression that big infrastructure projects will be enough to protect their populations" would do well to take note, Gemenne said.

The catastrophic flooding that ravaged parts of Germany and Belgium, as well as inundations in New York and cities in China should be a red flag, he warned.

"We need to collectively rethink where we can live, and where we can allow people to live."

For some countries, the forecasts are even more dramatic.

Tuvalu, the Marshall Islands and other low-lying island archipelagos risk disappearing entirely, raising fundamental questions about the very definition of a nation state.

If a country disappears physically, can they still have a seat at the UN?

Do their citizens -- living, perhaps, as refugees in another nation -- become stateless?

Can there be such a thing as a "virtual state"?

"Climate change is going to challenge the very foundations of international relations," Gemenne said.

A.Ragab--DT