Dubai Telegraph - Abuse scandal returns to haunt the flying 'butterflies' of Italian gymnastics

EUR -
AED 4.308724
AFN 77.53857
ALL 96.624273
AMD 447.449324
ANG 2.100573
AOA 1075.861168
ARS 1684.86077
AUD 1.766091
AWG 2.111833
AZN 1.988896
BAM 1.954268
BBD 2.36005
BDT 143.197773
BGN 1.953631
BHD 0.441754
BIF 3463.356168
BMD 1.173241
BND 1.513301
BOB 8.096654
BRL 6.357821
BSD 1.171782
BTN 105.96795
BWP 15.525832
BYN 3.454393
BYR 22995.513884
BZD 2.356653
CAD 1.615218
CDF 2628.058653
CHF 0.934175
CLF 0.027299
CLP 1070.938431
CNY 8.276619
CNH 8.270131
COP 4461.223553
CRC 586.140628
CUC 1.173241
CUP 31.090873
CVE 110.17865
CZK 24.273936
DJF 208.666463
DKK 7.469236
DOP 74.491619
DZD 151.490982
EGP 55.654426
ERN 17.598608
ETB 183.089309
FJD 2.665371
FKP 0.877875
GBP 0.878183
GEL 3.177275
GGP 0.877875
GHS 13.451458
GIP 0.877875
GMD 85.646688
GNF 10190.926274
GTQ 8.974966
GYD 245.147872
HKD 9.130451
HNL 30.849822
HRK 7.534556
HTG 153.58832
HUF 384.730253
IDR 19546.304125
ILS 3.784774
IMP 0.877875
INR 106.419599
IQD 1534.996987
IRR 49419.822308
ISK 148.384759
JEP 0.877875
JMD 187.612963
JOD 0.831772
JPY 181.906836
KES 151.641831
KGS 102.599728
KHR 4691.283347
KMF 492.162008
KPW 1055.916087
KRW 1726.335387
KWD 0.359835
KYD 0.976535
KZT 611.12105
LAK 25403.09101
LBP 104931.962394
LKR 362.076232
LRD 206.817912
LSL 19.769406
LTL 3.464274
LVL 0.709681
LYD 6.365012
MAD 10.780151
MDL 19.808476
MGA 5190.931747
MKD 61.501538
MMK 2462.943764
MNT 4160.152767
MOP 9.396136
MRU 46.894248
MUR 53.910621
MVR 18.092247
MWK 2031.907547
MXN 21.128747
MYR 4.798387
MZN 74.982124
NAD 19.769406
NGN 1701.257622
NIO 43.125834
NOK 11.885683
NPR 169.54912
NZD 2.030334
OMR 0.449118
PAB 1.171782
PEN 3.945108
PGK 5.050998
PHP 69.34788
PKR 328.388334
PLN 4.222082
PYG 7870.831447
QAR 4.270553
RON 5.091161
RSD 117.287579
RUB 93.312766
RWF 1705.463389
SAR 4.402231
SBD 9.593296
SCR 17.555092
SDG 705.707555
SEK 10.878268
SGD 1.514266
SHP 0.880234
SLE 28.304461
SLL 24602.271054
SOS 668.4761
SRD 45.226102
STD 24283.709675
STN 24.480605
SVC 10.252965
SYP 12972.146962
SZL 19.762512
THB 36.923643
TJS 10.76856
TMT 4.118074
TND 3.425515
TOP 2.824882
TRY 50.099481
TTD 7.951768
TWD 36.702469
TZS 2903.770373
UAH 49.510497
UGX 4164.736
USD 1.173241
UYU 45.983961
UZS 14116.876116
VES 313.771147
VND 30873.23725
VUV 142.111846
WST 3.256309
XAF 655.443314
XAG 0.018645
XAU 0.00027
XCD 3.170741
XCG 2.111845
XDR 0.815161
XOF 655.443314
XPF 119.331742
YER 279.815677
ZAR 19.775323
ZMK 10560.576536
ZMW 27.038809
ZWL 377.782964
  • SCS

    0.0200

    16.14

    +0.12%

  • CMSD

    -0.1500

    23.25

    -0.65%

  • BCE

    0.3100

    23.71

    +1.31%

  • GSK

    -0.0700

    48.81

    -0.14%

  • NGG

    0.2400

    74.93

    +0.32%

  • BCC

    0.2500

    76.51

    +0.33%

  • CMSC

    -0.1300

    23.3

    -0.56%

  • JRI

    -0.0200

    13.7

    -0.15%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    81.17

    0%

  • AZN

    -0.4600

    89.83

    -0.51%

  • BTI

    -1.2700

    57.1

    -2.22%

  • RIO

    -1.0800

    75.66

    -1.43%

  • RYCEF

    -0.2500

    14.6

    -1.71%

  • RELX

    0.1000

    40.38

    +0.25%

  • BP

    -0.2700

    35.26

    -0.77%

  • VOD

    0.0500

    12.59

    +0.4%

Abuse scandal returns to haunt the flying 'butterflies' of Italian gymnastics
Abuse scandal returns to haunt the flying 'butterflies' of Italian gymnastics / Photo: Lionel BONAVENTURE - AFP/File

Abuse scandal returns to haunt the flying 'butterflies' of Italian gymnastics

For more than two years, Nina Corradini was left feeling her hard-hitting accounts of abuse within Italian rhythmic gymnastics had all been for nothing.

Text size:

Corradini was, alongside double world champion Anna Basta, the first Italian gymnast to make public in October 2022 claims of abuse within the national set-up.

Basta said she had twice thought about killing herself, while Corradini herself quit the national team in 2021 after spending "every minute of the previous few months wishing I could escape".

Among other gymnasts who later made similar claims was Giulia Galtarossa, now 33 and world champion in 2009 and 2010, said she was berated by a coaching assistant for eating a pear, and handed her diet sheet with the message "we have a little piggy in the squad".

The affair seemed to have been closed in September 2023 when head coach Emanuela Maccarani was given a simple warning by the disciplinary tribunal of the country's gymnastics federation (FGI) and handed back the reins of the national team, nicknamed the "Butterflies".

But late last month the FGI, under new president Andrea Facci, sacked Maccarani, who has led Italy to the top of a sport traditionally dominated by countries from the former Soviet bloc.

The FGI's official explanation to AFP for her dismissal was that the organisation wanted to "open a new cycle in preparation for the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics".

But Corradini, silver medallist at the 2017 junior European Championships, is doubtful about the reasons given for Maccarani losing a job she had done with great success for nearly three decades.

"I think that everything Anna and I did played a part," she tells AFP.

"I'm pleased, not for any vengeful reasons, but because it means the young athletes now coming through to the national team will have a different experience to me."

For 29 years Maccarani reigned supreme at the Italian team's National Training Centre in Desio, not far from Milan, where she imposed a rigid regime in which days began with gymnasts being weighed in front of one another.

Maccarani and her assistant Olga Tishina insulted those who put on weight, calling them "pigs" and provoking eating disorders and suicidal thoughts in athletes who were barely out of childhood and often living far away from their families.

- Wiretap evidence -

"It was a bit like living in a bubble. Everything that happens to you seems normal. You're alone in this bubble -- that's all there is, and you don't see any way out," said Corradini, now 21 and a psychology student.

"It took me several months after I returned home to tell my parents about everything that happened."

Following Corradini, Basta and Galtarossa's allegations, prosecutors in Monza opened an investigation in which wiretaps were ordered for both FGI officials and the national team's management.

The subsequent 356-page report, seen by AFP, includes conversations between coaches mocking athletes and sexist remarks about a gymnast from both former FGI president Gherardo Tecchi and his successor Facci.

Extracts from these wiretaps published by the Gazzetta Dello Sport at the end of March featured Tishina criticising another coach, Julieta Cantaluppi, for apparently both forcing gymnasts to removing clothing "right down to their knickers" and locking them in a small, cold room if they made mistakes during training.

"I worked for four years with Julieta and none of that is true. She has nothing to do with Maccarani," Corradini insists.

The warning given to Maccarani was called "a total failure" by Daniela Simonetti, the founder of ChangeTheGame, an association that combats physical and psychological abuse in sport.

"What we have is an image of a federation where everyone looked out for one another and gave each other a helping had, starting with the former president," said Simonetti.

"We need to start again from scratch."

Corradini is in agreement: "If a girl has a psychological problem, she should see a psychologist. If she has a weight problem then she should see a nutritionist.

"Coaches don't know everything and need to learn to delegate responsibilities with people with more knowledge than them."

H.El-Qemzy--DT