Dubai Telegraph - For Ukraine's Roma, discrimination adds to agonies of war

EUR -
AED 3.878126
AFN 71.788991
ALL 98.337109
AMD 418.085316
ANG 1.902698
AOA 961.860832
ARS 1065.581837
AUD 1.623649
AWG 1.900531
AZN 1.797407
BAM 1.957089
BBD 2.131494
BDT 126.153104
BGN 1.960514
BHD 0.397977
BIF 3118.928467
BMD 1.055851
BND 1.418962
BOB 7.294771
BRL 6.326022
BSD 1.05569
BTN 89.144147
BWP 14.421842
BYN 3.454357
BYR 20694.670774
BZD 2.127912
CAD 1.479495
CDF 3030.291364
CHF 0.931867
CLF 0.037421
CLP 1032.525301
CNY 7.649428
CNH 7.653786
COP 4632.016362
CRC 539.152618
CUC 1.055851
CUP 27.98004
CVE 110.338209
CZK 25.260269
DJF 187.994733
DKK 7.458952
DOP 63.743501
DZD 141.019371
EGP 52.358705
ERN 15.837758
ETB 130.783335
FJD 2.395355
FKP 0.833401
GBP 0.832623
GEL 2.887735
GGP 0.833401
GHS 16.310668
GIP 0.833401
GMD 74.965981
GNF 9098.036486
GTQ 8.145559
GYD 220.796497
HKD 8.217986
HNL 26.709595
HRK 7.531655
HTG 138.404452
HUF 412.468245
IDR 16737.131744
ILS 3.855407
IMP 0.833401
INR 89.185159
IQD 1382.94377
IRR 44424.912138
ISK 144.926341
JEP 0.833401
JMD 166.330359
JOD 0.748919
JPY 159.876961
KES 136.95392
KGS 91.647615
KHR 4254.903697
KMF 492.539041
KPW 950.265094
KRW 1473.170197
KWD 0.324706
KYD 0.8798
KZT 540.633586
LAK 23169.372723
LBP 94535.928598
LKR 306.880707
LRD 189.499321
LSL 19.183647
LTL 3.117652
LVL 0.638673
LYD 5.150417
MAD 10.564559
MDL 19.330192
MGA 4929.270538
MKD 61.583358
MMK 3429.361399
MNT 3587.780111
MOP 8.462575
MRU 42.111941
MUR 49.098837
MVR 16.31292
MWK 1830.6146
MXN 21.490729
MYR 4.695367
MZN 67.472677
NAD 19.184192
NGN 1780.322276
NIO 38.845406
NOK 11.676836
NPR 142.630634
NZD 1.792327
OMR 0.406505
PAB 1.0557
PEN 3.96151
PGK 4.256804
PHP 61.969999
PKR 293.478441
PLN 4.305954
PYG 8233.423832
QAR 3.848053
RON 4.978256
RSD 117.00194
RUB 114.16436
RWF 1469.502841
SAR 3.966855
SBD 8.85921
SCR 14.416445
SDG 635.087268
SEK 11.525628
SGD 1.41721
SHP 0.833401
SLE 23.966772
SLL 22140.663103
SOS 603.311721
SRD 37.382386
STD 21853.974625
SVC 9.237129
SYP 2652.856032
SZL 19.192097
THB 36.301726
TJS 11.507035
TMT 3.706035
TND 3.334897
TOP 2.472908
TRY 36.53728
TTD 7.17376
TWD 34.364237
TZS 2793.369835
UAH 43.90433
UGX 3895.566234
USD 1.055851
UYU 45.220003
UZS 13581.010909
VES 49.410088
VND 26790.095998
VUV 125.352699
WST 2.947503
XAF 656.401843
XAG 0.034944
XAU 0.0004
XCD 2.853489
XDR 0.807551
XOF 656.392512
XPF 119.331742
YER 263.883423
ZAR 19.130692
ZMK 9503.924587
ZMW 28.476624
ZWL 339.983446
  • RELX

    0.2400

    47.05

    +0.51%

  • NGG

    0.5000

    63.33

    +0.79%

  • VOD

    0.1100

    8.97

    +1.23%

  • SCS

    -0.0700

    13.47

    -0.52%

  • RYCEF

    0.1100

    6.91

    +1.59%

  • RIO

    0.2900

    62.32

    +0.47%

  • CMSD

    -0.0700

    24.36

    -0.29%

  • RBGPF

    1.0000

    62

    +1.61%

  • CMSC

    -0.0500

    24.52

    -0.2%

  • GSK

    0.3100

    34.33

    +0.9%

  • AZN

    0.8400

    67.2

    +1.25%

  • BCC

    -2.0100

    146.4

    -1.37%

  • BCE

    0.3900

    27.02

    +1.44%

  • BTI

    0.2300

    37.94

    +0.61%

  • BP

    0.1700

    29.13

    +0.58%

  • JRI

    0.1700

    13.41

    +1.27%

For Ukraine's Roma, discrimination adds to agonies of war
For Ukraine's Roma, discrimination adds to agonies of war / Photo: Aleksey Filippov - AFP

For Ukraine's Roma, discrimination adds to agonies of war

Forced to flee fighting, Lyudmyla was assured the authorities would rehouse her in a town in western Ukraine. But when she arrived, they took one look at her and turned her away.

Text size:

"On the phone, it was OK. We agreed on the room. But when I arrived, they saw my dark skin and refused to give me shelter," she said.

A member of the Roma minority, this 59-year-old -- who prefers not to give her family name -- is by her own admission "a success story", being one of the few members of her community to have had an education.

And the same is true of her daughter, Ilona, who is a lawyer.

Together, they refused to be turned away, threatening to file a complaint, and only after a full day of haggling obtained the keys to the room where they spent one month along with Ilona's mother-in-law and three children.

"If I hadn't been educated, we would have had to sleep on the street or in the railway station," explained Lyudmyla, who has now returned to her home in Trebukhiv just to the west of Kyiv after Russian troops pulled back from the area to focus on southern and eastern Ukraine.

Like her, many of Ukraine's Roma population say they have struggled to access shelter and the aid that has poured in to the country since the Russians invaded on February 24.

- Rare complaints -

Census figures suggest there are some 50,000 Roma people in Ukraine, but rights groups say the figure is closer to 400,000.

"The biggest problem is housing: People don't want to host Roma families," says Julian Kondur of Chiricli, an international Ukraine-based charity that supports Roma women.

Like in many countries, long-held prejudices about the Roma people have fuelled a fear of them, he says.

On Wednesday, Human Rights Watch accused neighbouring Moldova of "deliberately housing most Roma refugees separately from others fleeing the war in Ukraine", denouncing the move as "unequal and discriminatory treatment".

Through its hotline, Chiricli has collected many testimonies about what happened during evacuations.

"A bus was about to leave (the northeastern city of) Kharkiv and the driver said 'no' to a Roma family," says Kondur, citing just one example.

"Sometimes, Roma themselves are so used to discrimination that they accept it as normal" and rarely complain, he says.

Lyudmyla initially told AFP she did not experience any discrimination, before then relating her experience.

Though she struggled to find shelter in western Ukraine, during the first two weeks of the war, Lyudmyla had offered refuge to around 50 other Roma in her basement.

Dressed in a long flowery dress, she recalled the fear and winter chill of those early days.

"Ten kilometres from here, there were Russian tanks and very heavy explosions. It was really scary," she said.

And it was so cold that one of her grandchildren became seriously ill.

- 'We're suffering too' -

Aside from the lack of solidarity shown towards their community, the Roma have also struggled to access certain types of aid because they do not have the right papers.

To avoid repression under the Soviet regime, the Roma did not register with the local authorities, and many do not have identity documents, birth certificates or passports to prove citizenship.

"At the time, there was a saying: If you don't have a passport, you don't have problems," Kondur says.

Since Ukraine became independent in 1991, many Roma people have moved to register, but around 30,000 still have not, putting them at a further disadvantage in wartime.

"Inevitably, you need to have identity documents to get food packages, to get financial support both from the government and the UN," he explains.

For all these reasons, Roma tend "to find help within their own community", says Valentina Zolotarenko, who works as a mediator to help her people access public services.

"On television, you see only Ukrainians, but we're suffering too," says the 59-year-old, who was born in Russia.

But "despite the bombs, I prefer being a Ukrainian Roma than a Russian one," she adds.

"It's far worse there for my community."

Y.Amjad--DT