Dubai Telegraph - BHP, Vale cleared by Brazil court over 2015 dam disaster

EUR -
AED 3.878381
AFN 70.7463
ALL 97.61914
AMD 408.610835
ANG 1.902881
AOA 962.990181
ARS 1056.133675
AUD 1.629831
AWG 1.903279
AZN 1.782367
BAM 1.961169
BBD 2.131736
BDT 126.165379
BGN 1.956257
BHD 0.39792
BIF 3059.500854
BMD 1.055911
BND 1.420876
BOB 7.295109
BRL 6.101267
BSD 1.05579
BTN 89.111243
BWP 14.492536
BYN 3.455159
BYR 20695.847018
BZD 2.128166
CAD 1.481395
CDF 3026.239678
CHF 0.937438
CLF 0.037319
CLP 1029.755569
CNY 7.634553
CNH 7.648657
COP 4732.327162
CRC 539.276272
CUC 1.055911
CUP 27.98163
CVE 110.765732
CZK 25.288741
DJF 187.656729
DKK 7.458477
DOP 63.830097
DZD 141.090833
EGP 52.228289
ERN 15.838658
ETB 128.873835
FJD 2.402218
FKP 0.833448
GBP 0.831266
GEL 2.877311
GGP 0.833448
GHS 16.947137
GIP 0.833448
GMD 74.96988
GNF 9113.563672
GTQ 8.153629
GYD 220.880478
HKD 8.217001
HNL 26.461494
HRK 7.532084
HTG 138.728456
HUF 406.280067
IDR 16819.863322
ILS 3.949333
IMP 0.833448
INR 89.184477
IQD 1383.770792
IRR 44459.114242
ISK 145.704916
JEP 0.833448
JMD 167.13754
JOD 0.74875
JPY 164.483941
KES 136.746848
KGS 91.20586
KHR 4277.493968
KMF 492.577276
KPW 950.319106
KRW 1481.96991
KWD 0.324608
KYD 0.879792
KZT 523.432901
LAK 23171.957081
LBP 94609.586688
LKR 308.454396
LRD 194.389971
LSL 19.270249
LTL 3.117829
LVL 0.63871
LYD 5.142547
MAD 10.51481
MDL 19.124993
MGA 4915.2638
MKD 61.493876
MMK 3429.556317
MNT 3587.984033
MOP 8.463609
MRU 42.104426
MUR 49.828585
MVR 16.313496
MWK 1833.060651
MXN 21.60902
MYR 4.731009
MZN 67.474328
NAD 19.270822
NGN 1773.781857
NIO 38.836002
NOK 11.721563
NPR 142.583725
NZD 1.797172
OMR 0.406548
PAB 1.05581
PEN 4.017209
PGK 4.154744
PHP 62.147202
PKR 293.595921
PLN 4.324907
PYG 8245.572309
QAR 3.844095
RON 4.976081
RSD 116.819612
RUB 104.856145
RWF 1441.317917
SAR 3.96598
SBD 8.852284
SCR 14.358481
SDG 635.128609
SEK 11.567089
SGD 1.418188
SHP 0.833448
SLE 23.948042
SLL 22141.921534
SOS 603.457557
SRD 37.333301
STD 21855.216762
SVC 9.23829
SYP 2653.006815
SZL 19.270107
THB 36.819919
TJS 11.254396
TMT 3.706246
TND 3.328196
TOP 2.473047
TRY 36.246349
TTD 7.168624
TWD 34.401037
TZS 2808.722543
UAH 43.524448
UGX 3874.606762
USD 1.055911
UYU 44.852785
UZS 13542.052761
VES 47.509864
VND 26820.128279
VUV 125.359824
WST 2.94767
XAF 657.745123
XAG 0.034607
XAU 0.00041
XCD 2.853651
XDR 0.79537
XOF 650.970195
XPF 119.331742
YER 263.819195
ZAR 19.211538
ZMK 9504.459219
ZMW 28.954812
ZWL 340.00277
  • RBGPF

    -0.9400

    59.25

    -1.59%

  • RYCEF

    -0.3200

    6.79

    -4.71%

  • SCS

    -0.1000

    13.27

    -0.75%

  • CMSC

    -0.0600

    24.55

    -0.24%

  • NGG

    0.2500

    62.37

    +0.4%

  • BCC

    -2.2000

    140.35

    -1.57%

  • RIO

    -0.1900

    60.43

    -0.31%

  • JRI

    -0.0300

    13.21

    -0.23%

  • BCE

    -0.3700

    26.84

    -1.38%

  • RELX

    -0.1700

    45.95

    -0.37%

  • CMSD

    -0.0050

    24.725

    -0.02%

  • VOD

    -0.0700

    8.68

    -0.81%

  • GSK

    -0.7200

    34.39

    -2.09%

  • BTI

    0.0700

    35.49

    +0.2%

  • AZN

    -0.2500

    65.04

    -0.38%

  • BP

    0.4800

    29.05

    +1.65%

BHP, Vale cleared by Brazil court over 2015 dam disaster
BHP, Vale cleared by Brazil court over 2015 dam disaster / Photo: Douglas Magno - AFP/File

BHP, Vale cleared by Brazil court over 2015 dam disaster

A Brazilian court on Thursday cleared mining giants BHP and Vale, and their Brazilian joint venture Samarco, of responsibility over a 2015 dam collapse that caused the country's worst ever environmental disaster.

Text size:

The dam's rupture on November 5, 2015 near the town of Mariana unleashed a giant torrent of toxic mud that swamped villages, rivers and rainforest, killing 19 people on its way to the sea.

Scientists say the sludge caused "permanent" pollution on the river Doce and its coastal plain.

Brazil's government filed a criminal complaint against the mining companies and several of their executives over the spill.

But a court in Belo Horizonte, capital of southeastern Minas Gerais state, where the disaster occurred, ruled that state prosecutors had failed to prove that "individual behavior contributed directly and decisively to the collapse of the dam.

"And, in the context of the criminal trial, the doubt... can only be resolved in favor of the accused," the judge wrote.

Pamela Rayane Fernandes, mother of Emanuele Vitoria, a five-year-old girl who died in the tragedy, reacted with disappointment to the companies' acquittal.

"Although I expected this response from the Brazilian justice system, it was still a shock to know that in the place where we live, where we come from, they (the state) cannot give us protection," she told AFP.

- $30 bn in damages -

The ruling comes nearly three weeks after Australia's BHP and Brazil's Vale reached a deal with Brazil's government to pay nearly $30 billion in damages over the collapse of the tailings dam at mine operated by Samarco.

The payout is the biggest of its kind for an environmental disaster, according to Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva.

The companies agreed to pay 100 billion reais (17.5 billion dollars) to local authorities over twenty years and 32 billion reais ($5.6 billion) towards compensating and resettling the victims, as well as repairing the harm caused to the environment.

Thursday's court decision also comes a month into a mega-trial in London over BHP's role in the mudslide.

More than 620,000 complainants, including 46 Brazilian municipalities and several Indigenous communities, are seeking an estimated £36 billion ($47 million) in damages from the company, which denies liability.

The dam's failure released a torrent of over 40 million cubic meters of sludge, the equivalent of 12,000 Olympic swimming pools, which flowed through the Doce river channel all the way to the Atlantic Ocean, over 600 kilometers (373 miles) away.

It killed thousands of animals and left over 600 people homeless.

Scientists say the mouth of the Doce River and parts of the southeast Atlantic coastline are still contaminated with metals from the spill, affecting the area's population of fish, birds, turtles, porpoises and whales.

BHP and Vale had already agreed in 2016 to pay 20 billion reais (about $3.5 billion at today's rate) in damages, but the negotiations were reopened in 2021 due to what the government called their "non-compliance".

I.Khan--DT