Dubai Telegraph - For profit or for all? Argentine football clubs red-card Milei reforms

EUR -
AED 3.826681
AFN 70.327616
ALL 98.192804
AMD 406.067937
ANG 1.879076
AOA 951.190259
ARS 1045.840133
AUD 1.601828
AWG 1.877897
AZN 1.775245
BAM 1.957546
BBD 2.105077
BDT 124.589901
BGN 1.956284
BHD 0.392592
BIF 3016.094951
BMD 1.041829
BND 1.405287
BOB 7.204528
BRL 6.043693
BSD 1.04263
BTN 88.005286
BWP 14.243906
BYN 3.412124
BYR 20419.848375
BZD 2.101624
CAD 1.456946
CDF 2991.091432
CHF 0.930994
CLF 0.037254
CLP 1027.952249
CNY 7.54601
CNH 7.562783
COP 4605.144632
CRC 531.073558
CUC 1.041829
CUP 27.608468
CVE 110.75048
CZK 25.343745
DJF 185.15426
DKK 7.457312
DOP 62.978972
DZD 139.891631
EGP 51.726992
ERN 15.627435
ETB 128.155793
FJD 2.371151
FKP 0.822333
GBP 0.831468
GEL 2.855018
GGP 0.822333
GHS 16.464915
GIP 0.822333
GMD 73.970229
GNF 8992.026458
GTQ 8.048177
GYD 218.127645
HKD 8.109446
HNL 26.28575
HRK 7.431636
HTG 136.86204
HUF 411.533277
IDR 16610.452733
ILS 3.863061
IMP 0.822333
INR 87.968134
IQD 1365.316903
IRR 43834.955489
ISK 145.523076
JEP 0.822333
JMD 166.09811
JOD 0.738765
JPY 161.242873
KES 134.920816
KGS 90.122166
KHR 4220.449639
KMF 492.268155
KPW 937.645704
KRW 1463.259646
KWD 0.320727
KYD 0.868887
KZT 520.591707
LAK 22878.565176
LBP 93347.878651
LKR 303.450587
LRD 187.529583
LSL 18.888757
LTL 3.076251
LVL 0.630192
LYD 5.089375
MAD 10.49591
MDL 19.017231
MGA 4865.341785
MKD 61.54739
MMK 3383.819949
MNT 3540.134882
MOP 8.359474
MRU 41.574227
MUR 48.810083
MVR 16.10707
MWK 1807.573672
MXN 21.281613
MYR 4.654932
MZN 66.583684
NAD 18.888753
NGN 1767.675143
NIO 38.287608
NOK 11.531328
NPR 140.808938
NZD 1.78585
OMR 0.401107
PAB 1.042655
PEN 3.952739
PGK 4.194144
PHP 61.404399
PKR 289.423952
PLN 4.338074
PYG 8139.257775
QAR 3.792783
RON 4.976404
RSD 117.038068
RUB 108.671879
RWF 1427.305728
SAR 3.911717
SBD 8.734231
SCR 14.879628
SDG 626.663972
SEK 11.501974
SGD 1.402827
SHP 0.822333
SLE 23.68116
SLL 21846.638123
SOS 595.409088
SRD 36.978718
STD 21563.75683
SVC 9.123047
SYP 2617.626467
SZL 18.888745
THB 35.91223
TJS 11.103861
TMT 3.646401
TND 3.313541
TOP 2.440072
TRY 36.018972
TTD 7.081314
TWD 33.946439
TZS 2771.265486
UAH 43.133048
UGX 3852.435216
USD 1.041829
UYU 44.339112
UZS 13366.666402
VES 48.506662
VND 26482.251319
VUV 123.688032
WST 2.90836
XAF 656.558208
XAG 0.033274
XAU 0.000384
XCD 2.815595
XDR 0.793126
XOF 650.625955
XPF 119.331742
YER 260.379151
ZAR 18.862746
ZMK 9377.71492
ZMW 28.802098
ZWL 335.468513
  • RBGPF

    59.2400

    59.24

    +100%

  • RIO

    -0.2200

    62.35

    -0.35%

  • GSK

    0.2600

    33.96

    +0.77%

  • SCS

    0.2300

    13.27

    +1.73%

  • NGG

    1.0296

    63.11

    +1.63%

  • CMSC

    0.0320

    24.672

    +0.13%

  • CMSD

    0.0150

    24.46

    +0.06%

  • RELX

    0.9900

    46.75

    +2.12%

  • BCC

    3.4200

    143.78

    +2.38%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0100

    6.79

    -0.15%

  • AZN

    1.3700

    65.63

    +2.09%

  • BCE

    0.0900

    26.77

    +0.34%

  • VOD

    0.1323

    8.73

    +1.52%

  • BTI

    0.4000

    37.38

    +1.07%

  • JRI

    -0.0200

    13.21

    -0.15%

  • BP

    0.2000

    29.72

    +0.67%

For profit or for all? Argentine football clubs red-card Milei reforms
For profit or for all? Argentine football clubs red-card Milei reforms / Photo: Luis Robayo - AFP

For profit or for all? Argentine football clubs red-card Milei reforms

A debate over the soul of football is raging in World Cup holders Argentina, pitting defenders of the social role of the beautiful game against the government of libertarian President Javier Milei, who wants to turn clubs into for-profit companies.

Text size:

Argentina, which gave the world Diego Maradona and Lionel Messi, is home to some of the world's most devoted football fans -- a fact attributed by supporters like Gabriel Nicosia to the clubs' community outreach.

Nicosia is a lifelong supporter of San Lorenzo, a more-than-century-old first division club based in the working-class Buenos Aires neighborhood of Boedo where he grew up.

Several times a week he crosses town to have a coffee or work out in the club of which Argentina-born Pope Francis is a fan.

"When I come here I meet my childhood friends. It's a fundamental pillar of everyday life," says the 50-year-old accountant, one of 80,000 members of a club whose stadium can only seat 48,000.

Membership can be acquired for a modest 22,000 pesos ($21) a month and comes with a vote on the club's management and tickets to local games.

The club's role as the glue that binds the community is underscored by the 300 scholarships it awards each year to young people from a nearby shantytown.

The recipients get to indulge their own dreams of fame and fortune by hanging out close to the training grounds of millionaire players.

Advocates of the not-for-profit model fear that this outreach could become a thing of the past if Milei manages to impose his free-marketeer vision on the clubs.

The president, an ardent defender of deregulation in all spheres of society, wants to change the statutes of the country's several thousand football clubs to allow them to become privately-owned for-profit companies.

- 'No-one cares' about owners -

During campaigning for president last year, Milei cited Buenos Aires' famous Boca Juniors, of which he is a fan, in arguing: "No-one cares who the owner is if you beat (arch-rivals) River Plate 5-0 and you win the Club World Cup."

The alternative, he said, was to "live with the misery that is Argentine football, which is deteriorating by the day."

He has pointed to Europe's top clubs, several of which are owned by Gulf states or, were previously, by Russian oligarchs as a model for his country.

But many Argentine clubs are firmly opposed to any change of ownership.

- Court setback for Milei -

"Our club belongs to its people, its members and its partners who make it greater each day," was Boca Juniors' rejoinder.

Argentine Football Association (AFA) president Claudio Tapia, who has one World Cup (2022) and two Copa America (2021, 2024) titles under his belt, has also made no secret of his opposition to the reforms.

It's "not our football model," Tapia, whose re-election to another four-year term in October was seen as a rebuke to Milei's reform, told an AFA assembly in August.

The president, a self-described "anarcho-capitalist", has forged ahead regardless.

In August, his government ordered the AFA to amend its statutes to allow for-profit clubs to join.

The decree was suspended by a court in September pending the outcome of a legal challenge by the AFA.

- Following Brazil's lead -

In Latin America, the pressure on clubs to open up to private investors is not unique to Argentina.

In 2021, Brazil changed its laws to allow for-profit clubs and Argentina's neighbour Uruguay has also adopted the model.

Some clubs see outside investment as a way to grow, attract new talent and ensure their funding into the future.

Membership fees "are not enough" to cover a club's costs, San Lorenzo director Martin Cigna said, adding that without TV rights and transfer fees his club would be running "a million-dollar deficit."

Former Argentina international Juan Sebastian Veron, who is president of another venerable club, Estudiantes, said they were preparing for a change to a "hybrid" model that would combine a "social" role with private funding.

Sports sociologist Veronica Moreira warned that a for-profit model would jeopardize club's non-commercial activities, with investors likely to "close anything that does not make a profit."

The ball is still up in the air but tensions are rising between the AFA and Milei.

The president has vowed to investigate "irregularities" at the AFA, whose leadership he has compared to that of authoritarian Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro.

But for the moment, football fans are on the AFA's side.

A poll carried out by the sports think tank Tactica showed 60.2 percent of Argentines interested in the sport opposed a change in the clubs' ownership.

A.El-Sewedy--DT