Dubai Telegraph - Brazil's shutdown of X fans debate over free speech curbs

EUR -
AED 4.100113
AFN 77.023391
ALL 99.447336
AMD 432.838798
ANG 2.014767
AOA 1036.468947
ARS 1074.711254
AUD 1.636359
AWG 2.00931
AZN 1.92827
BAM 1.957305
BBD 2.257155
BDT 133.59389
BGN 1.965384
BHD 0.42068
BIF 3230.523246
BMD 1.116283
BND 1.443523
BOB 7.725007
BRL 6.061866
BSD 1.117969
BTN 93.496501
BWP 14.707659
BYN 3.658545
BYR 21879.148453
BZD 2.253342
CAD 1.512678
CDF 3204.849171
CHF 0.945843
CLF 0.037658
CLP 1039.103456
CNY 7.8899
CNH 7.892758
COP 4648.481834
CRC 579.080293
CUC 1.116283
CUP 29.581502
CVE 110.791537
CZK 25.09505
DJF 198.385833
DKK 7.459342
DOP 67.201269
DZD 147.957368
EGP 54.174306
ERN 16.744246
ETB 128.657351
FJD 2.453423
FKP 0.850115
GBP 0.840299
GEL 3.047465
GGP 0.850115
GHS 17.524653
GIP 0.850115
GMD 76.468857
GNF 9658.645645
GTQ 8.64172
GYD 233.81355
HKD 8.700707
HNL 27.731566
HRK 7.589621
HTG 147.324568
HUF 394.065769
IDR 16940.712088
ILS 4.213405
IMP 0.850115
INR 93.347554
IQD 1462.33084
IRR 46987.14472
ISK 152.305694
JEP 0.850115
JMD 175.63501
JOD 0.791107
JPY 159.436514
KES 144.00081
KGS 94.074773
KHR 4543.271796
KMF 492.672047
KPW 1004.654143
KRW 1482.736164
KWD 0.3404
KYD 0.931512
KZT 535.361582
LAK 24653.111884
LBP 100018.964577
LKR 340.294632
LRD 216.83831
LSL 19.529721
LTL 3.296094
LVL 0.675228
LYD 5.325093
MAD 10.841334
MDL 19.50581
MGA 5036.894411
MKD 61.664335
MMK 3625.643914
MNT 3793.12987
MOP 8.973393
MRU 44.333165
MUR 51.204203
MVR 17.14598
MWK 1937.867679
MXN 21.522362
MYR 4.699547
MZN 71.274774
NAD 19.535528
NGN 1831.060868
NIO 41.137015
NOK 11.702609
NPR 149.612347
NZD 1.786209
OMR 0.429724
PAB 1.117969
PEN 4.180462
PGK 4.438412
PHP 62.045802
PKR 310.92129
PLN 4.272947
PYG 8726.786438
QAR 4.075633
RON 4.974608
RSD 117.069099
RUB 102.892984
RWF 1505.388617
SAR 4.18887
SBD 9.288327
SCR 15.203375
SDG 671.44267
SEK 11.337749
SGD 1.441813
SHP 0.850115
SLE 25.504058
SLL 23407.892397
SOS 638.896842
SRD 33.324404
STD 23104.806079
SVC 9.781519
SYP 2804.694667
SZL 19.535619
THB 37.004871
TJS 11.882003
TMT 3.906991
TND 3.375641
TOP 2.623048
TRY 37.953999
TTD 7.59799
TWD 35.642385
TZS 3041.24574
UAH 46.326211
UGX 4151.228228
USD 1.116283
UYU 45.925303
UZS 14242.075436
VEF 4043794.116249
VES 40.994414
VND 27438.238213
VUV 132.52737
WST 3.12276
XAF 656.485163
XAG 0.03591
XAU 0.000431
XCD 3.016811
XDR 0.828544
XOF 656.461621
XPF 119.331742
YER 279.433556
ZAR 19.537637
ZMK 10047.88601
ZMW 29.093234
ZWL 359.442698
  • RIO

    2.1500

    65.06

    +3.3%

  • CMSC

    -0.0050

    25.05

    -0.02%

  • SCS

    -0.9100

    13.2

    -6.89%

  • BTI

    -0.2750

    37.605

    -0.73%

  • NGG

    -1.2250

    68.825

    -1.78%

  • CMSD

    0.0400

    25.02

    +0.16%

  • AZN

    0.4350

    79.015

    +0.55%

  • RBGPF

    3.5000

    60.5

    +5.79%

  • BP

    0.4200

    32.85

    +1.28%

  • GSK

    -0.6250

    41.805

    -1.5%

  • RYCEF

    0.4000

    6.95

    +5.76%

  • BCE

    -0.3710

    35.239

    -1.05%

  • VOD

    -0.1700

    10.06

    -1.69%

  • BCC

    6.0200

    143.08

    +4.21%

  • JRI

    -0.0500

    13.39

    -0.37%

  • RELX

    0.6900

    48.06

    +1.44%

Brazil's shutdown of X fans debate over free speech curbs
Brazil's shutdown of X fans debate over free speech curbs / Photo: NELSON ALMEIDA - AFP

Brazil's shutdown of X fans debate over free speech curbs

Is Brazil's shutdown of Elon Musk's X a drastic but necessary move in the global fight against disinformation, or pure censorship?

Text size:

Supreme Court judge Alexandre de Moraes's decision to block the social media platform formerly known as Twitter has reignited a debate about where to draw the line between upholding free expression and combatting hate speech.

The shutdown affected 22 million X users in Brazil, many of whom have begun migrating to smaller platforms such as Bluesky and Threads to avoid hefty fines for using Musk's network.

Moraes blocked X in its biggest Latin American market after Musk refused to comply with orders to remove dozens of right-wing accounts and then failing to name a legal representative, as required under Brazilian law.

The showdown between the Brazilian and the US billionaire, who has been accused of turning X into a megaphone for right-wing conspiracy theories, comes amid growing scrutiny in the West of X and other social media titans.

In France, the Russian-born founder of the controversial Telegram app, Pavel Durov, was arrested last month and charged with failing to curb extremist and illegal content on his network, which has 900 million users.

TikTok, meanwhile, is in the crosshairs of the US Federal Trade Commission, which accuses it of violating child privacy laws.

But it is arguably Musk, a self-described "free speech absolutist" who has been using his platform to whip up support for right-wingers from Brazil to Britain, who is drawing the most fire.

The European Union is considering imposing a hefty fine on X and even a shutdown for possible violations of tough new social media regulations.

"Brazil has clearly joined the global debate on social media and free speech," Carl Tobias, a law professor at the University of Richmond in the United States, told AFP.

The shutdown of X in Brazil "reflects similar concerns about how best to regulate social media... in the US, many other democracies, and the EU," he said.

- 'Global problem' -

Afonso de Albuquerque, professor of communications at Rio's Federal Fluminense University, cast the Moraes-Musk dust-up as part of a wider battle for "the sovereignty of nations" against "powerful multi-millionaires."

"Elon Musk is a global problem", he told AFP.

The world's richest man, according to Forbes magazine, "bought Twitter and turned it into a political project, which has to do with to his involvement in far-right networks," Albuquerque asserted.

Musk has been a vociferous campaigner for the return of former US president Donald Trump to the White House.

He has also been vocal in his support for far-right Brazilian ex-president Jair Bolsonaro, whose supporters staged a failed US-style attack on government buildings in 2023 following his unsuccessful re-election bid.

- Brazil's 'democracy killer' -

Moraes's action against X has been applauded by the Brazilian left, including President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva.

"Who does (Musk) think he is?" Lula asked, arguing that democracy was "not the right to lie, spread hate or violate the will of the people."

Elvino Bohn Gass, an MP from Lula's Workers' Party, accused Musk of trying to "digitally colonize" Brazil.

But for Bolsonaro's supporters, the shutdown has become a cause celebre.

Thousands demonstrated in Sao Paulo on Saturday in defense of "democracy" and "liberty" against what they called Moraes's "censorship."

Some have disregarded the X ban, including Bolsonaro's son Eduardo, an MP, who accuses Moraes of "assassinating democracy."

- 'Political' move? -

Polls show Brazilians divided on the justification for the shutdown of X, with an AtlasIntel poll of over 1,600 people showing that 56.5 see it as a "political" move by Moraes.

Just over 54 percent declared it "weakens democracy," despite nearly half -- 49.7 percent -- expressing support for Moraes.

Beyond Brazil, the standoff is closely watched by both sides in what Britain's The Economist magazine called a "culture war battleground."

The Economist criticized the blocking of X as part of a growing trend to try to "censor and punish speech that should be within the law."

"Only with the freedom to be wrong can societies advance slowly towards what is right," the magazine argued.

A.El-Sewedy--DT