Dubai Telegraph - The difficult search for truth at France's biggest terror trial

EUR -
AED 3.868036
AFN 70.556841
ALL 97.357796
AMD 407.519973
ANG 1.897801
AOA 961.472489
ARS 1056.134523
AUD 1.631513
AWG 1.898198
AZN 1.779426
BAM 1.955933
BBD 2.126045
BDT 125.828557
BGN 1.951034
BHD 0.396857
BIF 3051.332951
BMD 1.053092
BND 1.417083
BOB 7.275633
BRL 6.097292
BSD 1.052972
BTN 88.873344
BWP 14.453846
BYN 3.445934
BYR 20640.595629
BZD 2.122485
CAD 1.480994
CDF 3018.160267
CHF 0.937677
CLF 0.037233
CLP 1027.375369
CNY 7.613956
CNH 7.638814
COP 4719.69334
CRC 537.836575
CUC 1.053092
CUP 27.906928
CVE 110.466774
CZK 25.286828
DJF 187.155704
DKK 7.458937
DOP 63.659602
DZD 140.713598
EGP 52.231872
ERN 15.796374
ETB 128.398185
FJD 2.395827
FKP 0.831223
GBP 0.831432
GEL 2.869651
GGP 0.831223
GHS 16.901937
GIP 0.831223
GMD 74.769391
GNF 9089.233891
GTQ 8.131862
GYD 220.290797
HKD 8.194764
HNL 26.411802
HRK 7.511975
HTG 138.358095
HUF 406.351196
IDR 16824.454893
ILS 3.944639
IMP 0.831223
INR 88.95786
IQD 1380.07656
IRR 44340.422562
ISK 145.674005
JEP 0.831223
JMD 166.691336
JOD 0.746746
JPY 164.795164
KES 136.376484
KGS 90.96237
KHR 4266.074143
KMF 491.266288
KPW 947.782053
KRW 1481.762471
KWD 0.323741
KYD 0.877443
KZT 522.0355
LAK 23110.095591
LBP 94357.008444
LKR 307.63092
LRD 193.874795
LSL 19.165476
LTL 3.109505
LVL 0.637004
LYD 5.138882
MAD 10.501957
MDL 19.073935
MGA 4907.406734
MKD 61.329706
MMK 3420.400483
MNT 3578.405247
MOP 8.441014
MRU 42.086842
MUR 49.695316
MVR 16.280487
MWK 1827.114148
MXN 21.541189
MYR 4.719428
MZN 67.239706
NAD 19.168622
NGN 1769.151713
NIO 38.711687
NOK 11.736063
NPR 142.203072
NZD 1.800618
OMR 0.405462
PAB 1.052992
PEN 4.006483
PGK 4.151551
PHP 62.05865
PKR 292.863531
PLN 4.322352
PYG 8223.559229
QAR 3.834043
RON 4.974905
RSD 116.507784
RUB 104.828879
RWF 1440.629328
SAR 3.955445
SBD 8.828472
SCR 15.52783
SDG 633.436063
SEK 11.584334
SGD 1.41773
SHP 0.831223
SLE 23.904752
SLL 22082.809581
SOS 601.843757
SRD 37.233631
STD 21796.87022
SVC 9.213627
SYP 2645.924123
SZL 19.171866
THB 36.847972
TJS 11.22435
TMT 3.685821
TND 3.319338
TOP 2.466445
TRY 36.265627
TTD 7.149486
TWD 34.311302
TZS 2801.224154
UAH 43.408252
UGX 3864.262783
USD 1.053092
UYU 44.733042
UZS 13479.572796
VES 47.863154
VND 26748.526988
VUV 125.025153
WST 2.939801
XAF 655.989151
XAG 0.034647
XAU 0.00041
XCD 2.846033
XDR 0.793246
XOF 653.440561
XPF 119.331742
YER 263.115098
ZAR 19.253853
ZMK 9479.091368
ZMW 28.877512
ZWL 339.09507
  • RBGPF

    -0.9400

    59.25

    -1.59%

  • JRI

    -0.0300

    13.21

    -0.23%

  • BCC

    -2.2000

    140.35

    -1.57%

  • SCS

    -0.1000

    13.27

    -0.75%

  • NGG

    0.2500

    62.37

    +0.4%

  • GSK

    -0.7200

    34.39

    -2.09%

  • RELX

    -0.1700

    45.95

    -0.37%

  • CMSD

    -0.0050

    24.725

    -0.02%

  • BTI

    0.0700

    35.49

    +0.2%

  • CMSC

    -0.0600

    24.55

    -0.24%

  • RIO

    -0.1900

    60.43

    -0.31%

  • RYCEF

    -0.3200

    6.79

    -4.71%

  • BCE

    -0.3700

    26.84

    -1.38%

  • BP

    0.4800

    29.05

    +1.65%

  • AZN

    -0.2500

    65.04

    -0.38%

  • VOD

    -0.0700

    8.68

    -0.81%

The difficult search for truth at France's biggest terror trial
The difficult search for truth at France's biggest terror trial / Photo: Benoit PEYRUCQ - AFP/File

The difficult search for truth at France's biggest terror trial

During the nine-month trial stemming from France's worst ever terror attacks in November 2015, the moment hundreds of victims were hoping for came late in proceedings.

Text size:

"I'm going to explain myself because it's the last time that I'll have the opportunity to do so," said Salah Abdeslam, the sole surviving Islamic State jihadist from the group that attacked the Bataclan concert hall and other targets in the French capital.

Spoken in the defendants' glass box in April, the words sent tremors through the courtroom where victims and their families had been ever-present during the hearings.

Those caught up in the carnage of November 13, 2015, had expressed different hopes for the trial, the biggest in French history which comes to climax this Wednesday when verdicts are expected.

Many survivors thought that by taking part, it would help them to heal psychologically. Others felt a deep desire for justice to be served, even though most of the attackers were dead.

And many more hoped for clarity: why had 10 young men from Muslim backgrounds, most of them born in Europe, slaughtered 130 people as they enjoyed themselves on a Friday night?

"We come here because we're trying to understand things which are completely irrational," a widow of a victim, who asked not to be named, told AFP as she headed into court in October.

She also hoped to meet people "who saw my husband just before he died," she added, her voice catching in her throat.

The attacks on the national sports stadium, bars in bustling neighbourhoods, and the Bataclan were the worst peace-time atrocity in modern French history.

The trial opened on September 8 and has been held in the specially built courtroom in central Paris -- an airy wood-framed construction, with chairs and benches for 550 people.

For some, the desire for explanations seemed in vain.

Abdeslam "thinks he's a star, he teases us, keeps quiet, enjoys the reactions he provokes," one of the prosecution lawyers, Nicolas Le Bris, said angrily in late March.

Two weeks later, the main suspect, wearing a striped t-shirt and blue jacket, appeared to have a change of heart.

"All these people in here need my responses. I can't promise anything, but I'll do my best," said the 32-year-old, who had refused to cooperate during his six years behind bars.

- 'Not going to do it' -

The Belgium-born son of Moroccan immigrants recounted what he said was his role in the attacks that sent shockwaves through France and Europe.

During a meeting in Belgium, where the IS cell was based, he had been asked to take part in the attacks two days beforehand by the ringleader, Abdelhamid Abaaoud, a long-time friend.

During the assault, which was coordinated from Syria, Abdeslam's role was to blow himself up in a cafe in a fashionable area of the 18th district of northern Paris.

Before this, he would drive three suicide bombers to the Stade de France where France was playing Germany in a football game attended by then-president Francois Hollande.

But when he arrived in the bar, he had a change of heart, Abdeslam claimed.

"I go into the cafe, I order a drink, I look at the people around me and I say to myself 'no, I'm not going to do it'," he told the court.

A few kilometres to the southeast, his older brother Brahim embraced his mission, gunning down young people in cafes before blowing himself up.

A third group of jihadists ran into the Bataclan during an Eagles of Death Metal concert, shooting indiscriminately. Ninety people died there.

After his alleged change of heart, Abdeslam said he travelled to the south of Paris before calling some friends in Brussels to come to pick him up.

He went on the run for four months before being found by Belgian police in his home neighbourhood of Molenbeek in the Belgian capital, living close to his family.

- Tears -

The apparent breakthrough moment in court raised as many questions as it answered -- and Abdeslam refused or evaded follow-ups.

Prosecutors had detailed how his suicide belt, later found by police, had in fact been defective.

This was a more likely explanation of why he had not detonated, they said.

He had booked cars and rooms for fellow attackers in his own name in Paris, a lack of precaution suggesting he did not intend to survive.

And in handwritten letters found afterwards, including to his sister, he justified the attacks on "sinners" and regretted that he had not ended up among the "martyrs".

When asked in court, he wouldn't give the name of the bar he visited, or explain why he had acted alone while the other attackers were in threes.

"I changed my mind out of humanity, not out of fear," he insisted.

"A fairy tale," the head of a victims' association said afterwards.

Two days later, a weeping Abdesalam presented his "condolences and apologies" in court.

"I know that there is still hate... I ask you to hate me with moderation," he pleaded.

Had a man who began the trial dressed in black and defiantly giving his profession as an "Islamic State fighter" been affected by the months of heart-wrenching testimony?

Or was he trying to save his skin, having told the court of his suffering in solitary confinement and fearing a lifetime behind bars?

- Therapeutic justice -

The trial has been unprecedented for France in scale and complexity.

The investigation took six years and its written conclusions stretch to 53 metres (174 feet) when lined up.

Apart from Abdeslam, 19 others are on trial, including other suspected members of the Brussels-based Islamic State cell, and people accused of offering logistical support.

But the time given over to victims to testify has also set the trial apart, lending it at times the sense of a mass therapy session.

"I needed to feel the Bataclan, hear the bullets, the smell," bereaved father Stephane said after witness statements in October.

He had been able to imagine what his son Hugo "felt that evening", he said.

The filming of proceedings for the national archives -- recordings in French courts are usually banned -- means the trial will serve as a historical resource.

"When you take part you hear about everyone else's stories, what they suffered, what they lost," David Fritz Goeppinger, a hostage in the Bataclan, told AFP recently.

- Verdicts Wednesday -

In their concluding arguments, prosecutors condemned Abdesalam's display of emotion in court as a cynical ploy to encourage leniency from the five magistrates who will decide his fate.

By taking part in the operation he had "the blood of all the victims on his hands," they said.

Though his guilt as a participant is not in doubt, the judges will have to decide whether to agree to prosecutors' demands for a life sentence without the possibility of parole.

Much will hinge on whether they believe the one-time drug dealer who never once condemned Islamic State's atrocities is capable of remorse and poses a threat for the rest of his days.

Arthur Denouveaux, head of the Life for Paris survivors' group, said that after eight gruelling months people were now fed up.

"I'm not that interested in the verdicts in themselves. It's really about saying 'that's it. It's behind us. The justice system has done its work, we can move on'," he told AFP.

asl-aje-mdh-adp/sjw/jv

G.Koya--DT