Dubai Telegraph - Peru farmer in German court battle with energy giant

EUR -
AED 3.998253
AFN 76.937614
ALL 99.458929
AMD 426.646141
ANG 1.964094
AOA 992.841766
ARS 1160.597233
AUD 1.716168
AWG 1.959557
AZN 1.853551
BAM 1.956012
BBD 2.200398
BDT 132.41432
BGN 1.958991
BHD 0.410144
BIF 3229.149226
BMD 1.088643
BND 1.454557
BOB 7.530814
BRL 6.288765
BSD 1.089798
BTN 94.726374
BWP 14.847333
BYN 3.566486
BYR 21337.3976
BZD 2.189017
CAD 1.563329
CDF 3130.936959
CHF 0.961767
CLF 0.02643
CLP 1014.244884
CNY 7.879432
CNH 7.881599
COP 4496.780339
CRC 544.45388
CUC 1.088643
CUP 28.849032
CVE 110.276926
CZK 25.017658
DJF 194.057422
DKK 7.461111
DOP 68.526782
DZD 145.057355
EGP 54.967421
ERN 16.329641
ETB 143.139765
FJD 2.490107
FKP 0.841311
GBP 0.840884
GEL 3.020971
GGP 0.841311
GHS 16.891827
GIP 0.841311
GMD 78.382426
GNF 9424.01919
GTQ 8.401909
GYD 228.004658
HKD 8.459963
HNL 27.870758
HRK 7.535476
HTG 142.925457
HUF 399.68321
IDR 17864.627276
ILS 3.98243
IMP 0.841311
INR 94.520859
IQD 1427.654398
IRR 45831.858923
ISK 146.30272
JEP 0.841311
JMD 170.66689
JOD 0.771954
JPY 162.111424
KES 140.967835
KGS 95.201661
KHR 4366.472226
KMF 491.90305
KPW 979.778461
KRW 1576.985391
KWD 0.335346
KYD 0.908198
KZT 546.179068
LAK 23607.553113
LBP 97645.460173
LKR 323.014933
LRD 217.949567
LSL 19.828344
LTL 3.214479
LVL 0.658509
LYD 5.246471
MAD 10.547241
MDL 19.393097
MGA 5081.502878
MKD 61.536655
MMK 2286.132381
MNT 3780.292197
MOP 8.724244
MRU 43.307286
MUR 49.043527
MVR 16.775768
MWK 1889.687008
MXN 21.715037
MYR 4.842316
MZN 69.555432
NAD 19.828344
NGN 1674.691713
NIO 40.104337
NOK 11.517829
NPR 151.561999
NZD 1.884914
OMR 0.419078
PAB 1.089818
PEN 3.997732
PGK 4.479443
PHP 62.373778
PKR 305.272606
PLN 4.17823
PYG 8652.776817
QAR 3.97203
RON 4.97734
RSD 117.154317
RUB 91.826609
RWF 1530.851497
SAR 4.083029
SBD 9.156736
SCR 15.652393
SDG 654.274245
SEK 11.010462
SGD 1.452042
SHP 0.855502
SLE 24.853963
SLL 22828.295003
SOS 622.86164
SRD 39.538403
STD 22532.706647
SVC 9.536031
SYP 14154.468258
SZL 19.834781
THB 36.61
TJS 11.878785
TMT 3.821136
TND 3.366964
TOP 2.549711
TRY 39.924923
TTD 7.3998
TWD 35.927928
TZS 2890.884277
UAH 45.206874
UGX 3994.43199
USD 1.088643
UYU 46.44481
UZS 14116.526676
VES 69.789057
VND 27798.49223
VUV 133.856716
WST 3.068335
XAF 656.021921
XAG 0.032276
XAU 0.000364
XCD 2.942112
XDR 0.815881
XOF 656.015895
XPF 119.331742
YER 268.622547
ZAR 19.802112
ZMK 9799.085827
ZMW 31.195087
ZWL 350.542516
  • AZN

    1.0900

    77.6

    +1.4%

  • CMSC

    0.0500

    23.22

    +0.22%

  • RBGPF

    66.0200

    66.02

    +100%

  • RYCEF

    0.0500

    10.4

    +0.48%

  • NGG

    0.8900

    63.21

    +1.41%

  • RIO

    1.8400

    63.04

    +2.92%

  • BTI

    -0.0200

    41.36

    -0.05%

  • RELX

    1.1200

    48.93

    +2.29%

  • SCS

    0.2000

    10.99

    +1.82%

  • GSK

    0.2600

    39.49

    +0.66%

  • BCC

    2.9700

    99.35

    +2.99%

  • CMSD

    0.1500

    23.35

    +0.64%

  • BCE

    -0.1990

    23.47

    -0.85%

  • JRI

    0.0335

    12.83

    +0.26%

  • BP

    1.0200

    33.39

    +3.05%

  • VOD

    0.0500

    9.55

    +0.52%

Peru farmer in German court battle with energy giant
Peru farmer in German court battle with energy giant / Photo: Luka GONZALES - AFP

Peru farmer in German court battle with energy giant

A Peruvian farmer faces off in a German court Monday in a "David and Goliath" battle against an energy giant, demanding the firm pay for climate change damage.

Text size:

Saul Luciano Lliuya, 44, argues that electricity producer RWE -- one of the world's top emitters of climate-altering carbon dioxide -- must share the cost of protecting his hometown Huaraz from a swollen glacier lake at risk of overflowing from melting snow and ice.

He wants the German company to pay 17,000 euros ($18,400) towards flood defences for his community, arguing that the fossil fuels the firm uses to generate electricity make it partly responsible for the flood risk.

"What I am asking is for the company to take responsibility for part of the construction costs," he said at a press conference in Lima earlier this month.

"I have full confidence in these processes."

However much confidence Lliuya has in proceedings, they have moved at a glacial pace.

He first filed a lawsuit in 2015 but a court in the western German city of Essen, where RWE is headquartered, dismissed it the following year.

However, in 2017 a higher court in the city of Hamm, also in western Germany, allowed an appeal.

After a delay due to the Covid pandemic, hearings are scheduled from Monday to Wednesday, and Lliuya will be attending.

"I would never have thought that it would all take so long," Lliuya told Germanwatch, a German environmental NGO supporting him in the case.

- 'Fair contribution' -

The hearing will ask if Lliuya's property in Peru's Ancash region is at substantial risk of flooding, examining evidence collected by court-appointed experts who travelled to the area in 2022.

If confirmed, a subsequent hearing would look at the question of RWE's responsibility.

Lliuya bases his claim on a 2014 study that concluded RWE was responsible for 0.47 percent of all global carbon emissions since the start of the industrial era.

RWE, which has never operated in Peru, should pay that share of the 3.5 million euros it would cost to lower the waters of Lake Palcacocha, he says.

Founded in 1898, RWE power plants today use a variety of power sources including solar, wind, gas and coal.

"It is time for companies like RWE to make a fair contribution to the costs of the damage they have helped to cause," said Francesca Mascha Klein, legal officer at Germanwatch.

RWE says a court ruling in favour of Lliuya would set a precedent of holding people responsible under German law for actions that have environmental consequences far outside the country.

"We think that is legally inadmissible and the wrong way to address this issue socially and politically," a spokesman said.

Dismissing the case in 2015, the Essen court said that it was impossible to draw a link between particular emissions and particular damage.

The Hamm hearing might be the first stage towards overturning that opinion at a time when 43 climate-damage cases are ongoing worldwide, according to Zero Carbon Analytics, a not-for-profit research group.

Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer, the law firm representing RWE, says that there could be major implications: "The sum in dispute may be less than 20,000 euros. But the precedent-setting potential is clear."

R.El-Zarouni--DT